Redesigning onboarding to make the valuable action visible.
Families who invited sitters to apply were twice as likely to convert to premium. The problem? That action was hard to find. I redesigned the journey to bring it forward.

The brief was simple: help Sittercity make more money.
Sittercity connects families with local babysitters and nannies. Most revenue comes from families upgrading to premium, so the question from leadership was clear: how do we get more families to upgrade?
I was one of two designers and owned the sitter and matching side. This project touched both sides, so I partnered closely with our PM from day one.
Our PM and I dug into the data and found one behavior that mattered most.
Families who invite a sitter to apply to their job are twice as likely to upgrade to premium as families who don’t.
That reframed the whole project. We didn’t need a brand new feature. We needed more families to use the one we already had.
So why weren’t more families sending invites? I started asking around.
I talked to people across the company. Someone at our parent company told me they didn’t even know you could invite a sitter to apply.
That was the answer. Invite to Apply was hidden behind the Contact button on sitter profiles. If people who work with the product missed it, families definitely did.
“It wasn’t a motivation problem. It was a visibility problem.”
Anthony Myrick-Lawson · Discovery synthesis
I ran two bets at once. The first: an A/B test to pull the invite out of hiding.
Rather than wait on a big rebuild, I proposed a small, isolated A/B test: move Invite to Apply out of the Contact menu and put it right on the sitter profile.
It was fast for engineering to ship and gave us real evidence before anyone committed to bigger changes.
Control
The old version: Invite to Apply hidden under Contact on sitter profiles.
Variant
Invite to Apply front and center on sitter profiles.
Result
The visible version drove a statistically significant increase in invite actions, moving more new families into the highest-converting group. We measured invites, not premium upgrades directly, and the test was still running when I left.
While the test ran, I audited Care.com and UrbanSitter to see what families were used to.
I wanted to know how competitors bring in new families, and whether anything in their experience was meaningfully different from ours.
Something was. When families finish posting a job, both competitors skip the dashboard. They drop families straight into sitter search with their job requirements already filled in.
Care.com: filtered sitter search
Care.com takes families straight to sitters that match their needs.
UrbanSitter: guided next steps
UrbanSitter explains what happens next and walks families into matching.
Posting a job was a dead end. Our dashboard just said “here’s your job.”
After posting, families landed on a dashboard that showed the job they’d just created. That was it. No sitters, no actions, nothing pulling them forward.
Competitors were building momentum at the exact moment we were losing it. That became the second half of the project.
Invite to Apply hid in secondary menus, and nothing guided families after they posted.
Surface the invite, guide families into matching sitters after posting, and give the dashboard a clear checklist.
I designed a new path from “job posted” to “here are your sitters.”
Instead of a dead end, families now move through four short screens that teach them about invites and hand them real matches.
Welcome + How It Works
Right after posting, families are welcomed to Sittercity and shown how it works, including that they can invite sitters to apply. The feature is introduced on day one instead of hidden.
Filtered Sitter Match
Next, a short “we’re finding sitters that meet your needs” moment shows the product working for them. Then families see three sitters in their area, with the option to see the full list in sitter search, already filtered by their job.
Then I pitched a checklist so the dashboard always had a next step.
The first time families visit home, they see a three-step Get Started checklist. Every step was chosen on purpose.
1. Create a job (already done)
Families have already done this to get here, so they start at 33%, not zero. Starting with progress makes people more likely to finish.
2. Add a photo
We knew families with photos got more legitimate applications, so this step improves the quality of what they get back.
3. Invite your first sitter
The behavior tied to 2× upgrades, now a clear goal on the home screen instead of a hidden menu item.
Every screen after that points to the same next step.
Profiles, search, and the dashboard all lead back to inviting a sitter. Bold buttons and clear status labels make it easy to tell what you can do from what you’ve already done.
Sitter profile: contact and status
The profile keeps the guidance going, with Invite to Apply visible and clear status info.
The biggest win wasn’t a new feature. It was making the right one impossible to miss.
The test proved that showing the invite gets more families to use it. The new onboarding and checklist turn posting a job into a guided start instead of a dead end.
To be clear about the 2×: families who invite are twice as likely to upgrade. It’s not a claim that this redesign doubled overall conversion. I left before we could measure the full effect on upgrades.
“Sometimes the most impactful design decision isn’t a new feature, it’s making an existing one impossible to miss.”
Anthony Myrick-Lawson · Project reflection
likelihood of premium conversion for families completing the target action